A new paper from the School of Underlying Conditions proposes a single support measure to sit beside every efficiency rating, and finds that 20 of the 41 plants it rates as inefficient are compared against targets that lie far from any plant in the sample.
A study of 58 manufacturing plants asks which innovation ratings rest on comparisons with a plant no one has observed
A soil surveyor learns early to mark the difference between a boundary seen in a pit and one inferred between two auger holes. The School of Underlying Conditions has now carried that habit to the factory floor.
In Scored Against a Plant Nobody Built, Dr Brynjar Obiora, Dr Lindiwe Achterberg and Dr Mirela Hanke revisit the familiar efficiency league table for 58 manufacturing plants and their programmes of process innovation, and ask of each rating how near it stands to anything actually observed. For 20 of the 41 plants rated inefficient, the answer is: not very.
Every plant that opened its trial records to the survey gave us a point on the frontier, and when points are this scarce each one is worth a great deal. We are grateful to all of them.
— Dr Brynjar Obiora, Senior Research Fellow, School of Underlying Conditions
The team brings survey practice, frontier estimation and a careful accounting of where the evidence thins into a single support measure, designed to travel alongside each rating and to make the reach of every comparison visible to the people who rely on it.
Dr Achterberg said the collaboration had given her “a new regard for the ground between two things that are already known”.
The University sees in the paper the kind of exchange between disciplines it has always made room for, in which a way of looking learned in one field turns out to be what another field was missing.
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.aravej.