Skip to main content
Field-camp students will no longer mark themselves

Field-camp students will no longer mark themselves

A paper from the School of Underlying Conditions proposes an impartial way to divide a field-mapping team's mark, and the School will use it at its next camp.

A new paper sets out a peer-report rule in which a student's own points cannot move their own mark

At the next field-mapping camp of the School of Underlying Conditions, the points a student gives themselves on the last evening will no longer count towards their mark. The change follows Nobody Marks Themselves, a new paper by Associate Professor Ragnhild Uzoma, Lead of the Basement Relations Group, with Dr Torun Ezeigwe, Senior Lecturer and Director of the Master of Applied Measurement, and Dr Vigdis Emenike, Senior Lecturer in the School.

The paper brings the School’s fieldwork tradition into conversation with assessment design, reframing the shared team mark as an allocation challenge and aligning the camp’s contribution process with a principle of impartiality. Working across three cohorts of contribution statements, the authors find that the new approach recalibrates individual outcomes at the margins while keeping each team’s overall result intact.

A camp is where students first learn to write down only what they saw. It seemed fair to ask the same of the form we hand them on the final night.

— Associate Professor Ragnhild Uzoma, Lead of the Basement Relations Group

For Dr Ezeigwe, the paper sits within a longer University conversation about how instruments settle into teaching. “Every marking scheme eventually teaches something of its own,” she said. “This one will, too, and the School intends to be listening when it does.”

The work stands as a measure of the University’s readiness to turn its research lens on its own classrooms, and of a School prepared to redesign a procedure it built.

The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.k4bmiw.