A formal model from the School of Emergent Priorities explains how a pilot that no member wants extended can stay in trial status for as long as its committee stays divided.
A new paper models a committee that needs a supermajority to confirm or end a trial, and finds renewal is where it settles
Divided committees keep pilots alive for reasons that have little to do with the pilots themselves, according to Neither Confirmed nor Terminated, a new paper by Dr Lindiwe Achterberg, Lecturer, and Dr Ingrid Vasseur, Lecturer and Convenor of Futures in Committee, both of the School of Emergent Priorities.
Every organisation has a decision it is still in the middle of making. Our hope is that the paper helps people see that middle as a place with a structure of its own, rather than a delay on the way somewhere else.
— Dr Lindiwe Achterberg, Lecturer, School of Emergent Priorities
The paper brings the tools of game theory to bear on a familiar institutional setting: a standing committee that can confirm a trial or wind it up, but only with a supermajority, and that carries the trial forward when it does neither. Its model shows how each side’s ability to block the other turns renewal into a stable resting point, and how the gradual turnover of a committee’s membership, rather than any change of view, ultimately settles the matter. On the paper’s figures, a committee of thirteen working to a two-thirds rule can expect to renew a pilot around sixteen times before deciding it. The authors also set out a sunset arrangement under which the resting point disappears.
The University regards the paper as a careful and timely addition to the School’s work on how organisations hold their options open. Dr Vasseur said Futures in Committee would take the paper up in the coming semester. “Much of the School’s thinking becomes practice in a committee room,” she said, “so it seems right that this paper should be discussed in one.”
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.zatrh2.