Skip to main content
Readers hear a budget deficit cross the line at three per cent

Readers hear a budget deficit cross the line at three per cent

A research poster from the School of Underlying Conditions finds that readers tell budget deficits apart best where they cross a 3% reference value, and that training in fiscal surveillance sharpens the effect.

A research poster borrows a test from speech science to ask how lay and trained readers perceive a fiscal reference value

Ask whether a deficit of 3.25 per cent is much worse than one of 2.75, and the arithmetical answer is that it is half a point worse. The readers in a new research poster from the School of Underlying Conditions did not hear it that way.

Across the Line at Three, by Dr Vigdis Emenike, Associate Professor Kwame Lindqvist and Ms Gunnhild Ekwueme, asked 144 adults to compare short budget summaries for a fictional member state. Pairs that straddled the 3% reference value were told apart far more readily than pairs with the same spacing on either side of it, and most readily by those trained to watch for it.

A bore teaches you that a reading means whatever the line drawn beside it says it means. The School has now found the same is true of people, and intends to take that back underground with it.

— Dr Vigdis Emenike, Senior Lecturer, School of Underlying Conditions

The study brings the laboratory paradigms of speech perception into dialogue with the architecture of fiscal surveillance, positioning the reference value as a perceptual as well as a procedural instrument. It also takes the School, the University notes with some satisfaction, a long way above the water table.

Associate Professor Lindqvist welcomed a result “that leaves the reference value exactly where it found it, which in public finance is a considerable courtesy”.

The full poster is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.r1bza9.