A new paper from the School of Continuous Improvement and the School of Emergent Priorities follows 412 employee sustainability suggestions through a manufacturer's four-gate idea scheme, and finds that most were neither adopted nor declined.
At one manufacturer, half of 412 suggestions were held rather than declined, and most that advanced had been rewritten in the language of cost
What becomes of a good idea that nobody turns down? For Dr Solveig Adeyemi, Lecturer and Deputy Convenor, Review Cadence Observatory, the question has a precise address: the “on hold” column of a workplace idea scheme.
In Parked, Not Rejected, Dr Adeyemi, Ms Edda Nwafor of the School of Continuous Improvement and Dr Lindiwe Achterberg of the School of Emergent Priorities follow 412 sustainability suggestions made by staff at one manufacturer across six years and four review gates. Fewer than one in four was implemented and only one in seven was declined. Nearly half were held, many for more than two years, and those that kept moving had usually been rewritten by a manager into an argument about cost.
Everyone at the site wanted the ideas to come through, and the project let us see, very patiently, how that wish takes shape on a form. We are grateful to the people who let us watch it happen.
— Dr Solveig Adeyemi, Lecturer and Deputy Convenor, Review Cadence Observatory
Bringing platform records, review minutes and conversations with proposers, managers and panel members into a single account, the study maps the suggestion journey end to end, from first submission through the decisions, and the pauses, that shape it. The paper extends a line of inquiry the University has increasingly made its own: what happens to a contribution between the moment it is offered and the moment it is acted upon.
Dr Achterberg said the team “came out of the archive with more questions than we took in, which for a School like ours is a very good sign.”
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.kqwign.