Skip to main content
University researchers set a rule for when to stop watching the ground

University researchers set a rule for when to stop watching the ground

A new paper from the School of Settled Matters and the School of Underlying Conditions proposes a way to decide when disturbed ground has finished settling and the surveys over it can stop.

Twenty-six months of resistivity surveys over a refilled trench find that the obvious way to end a monitoring campaign ends it too soon

Once a month for more than two years, a line of 48 steel stakes across a grazed paddock has been asked how a refilled cable trench was getting on. Deciding When to Stop, a new paper by Dr Odalys Penhallow of the School of Settled Matters with Dr Brynjar Obiora and Dr Vigdis Emenike of the School of Underlying Conditions, sets out what those answers say about when such a campaign should end.

The team finds that the most intuitive rule, stopping once one month’s survey agrees with the last, would have closed the campaign at month 7 with nearly a quarter of the change still to come. A rule built on the change still ahead, rather than the change just seen, waited until month 15.

Every project reaches a point where it has to decide it is finished. It has been a privilege to spend two years learning how to say so with some confidence, alongside colleagues who know the ground far better than I do.

— Dr Odalys Penhallow, Senior Lecturer, School of Settled Matters

The paper aligns near-surface geophysics, soil survey practice and a repeatability-led approach to decision-making into a single framework for monitoring disturbed ground across its full settlement trajectory. Dr Obiora said the trench had “given the soil survey a good deal to think about, most of it from a respectful distance”.

The University regards the paper as a fine instance of two Schools sharing a field site, a question and a great deal of patience, and thanks the landholder whose paddock hosted the line for as long as the question needed.

The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.va9cqc.