Skip to main content
Soil-survey curves widen when the senior surveyor is in the room

Soil-survey curves widen when the senior surveyor is in the room

A School of Underlying Conditions research poster follows a soil-survey team through four workshops at which it drew fuzzy membership functions for its drainage classes, and finds imperfectly drained drawn three times as wide when the senior surveyor attended.

A year in the pits and the meeting room with one survey team shows how a drainage class becomes the safe word

Four workshops, nine surveyors and a large sheet of paper pinned to a meeting-room wall sit at the centre of The Class You Write When You’d Rather Not Be Asked, a new research poster from the School of Underlying Conditions by Associate Professor Ragnhild Uzoma, Dr Anneke Tolan and Dr Bram Ntuli.

The team spent fourteen months alongside a regional soil-survey unit, at the pit face and in the room where its members turned their drainage classes into curves for a land-evaluation model. Bringing field observation, interviews and the workshops’ own drawings into a single account of expert judgement in practice, the poster finds that the class “imperfectly drained” was given full membership across 45 cm of depth to mottling when the senior surveyor attended, and across 15 cm when fieldwork kept them away. Junior staff, it reports, knew it as the class nobody asks you about.

The University has always held that the way colleagues arrive at a word deserves as much care as the word itself. This poster is a welcome addition to that conviction.

— Dr Anneke Tolan, Senior Research Fellow and Deputy Convenor, Futures in Committee

The work adds to the University’s steadily widening interest in how expert judgement is reached, recorded and passed on, and to the Basement Relations Group’s long engagement with the people who describe the ground.

“Elicitation is often treated as the quiet part of building a model,” said Dr Ntuli, Lecturer and Convenor, Improvement Grand Rounds. “It has been good to spend some time in the louder part.”

The full poster is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.514x4w.