The School of Continuous Improvement's Impact Report 2021–2026 reviews the decision protocols it drafted with collaborators on interdisciplinary projects, and what became of the casting votes they assigned.
The School of Continuous Improvement looks back on the protocols that settle whose discipline decides when a joint project's experts disagree
When a joint project’s experts disagree, someone has to have the last word. For five years the School of Continuous Improvement has been helping collaborators decide who that will be before the work begins, and its Impact Report 2021–2026, The Casting Vote, looks back on what came of it.
A protocol is a conversation a team agrees to have before it needs to. We are grateful to every collaborator who agreed to have it with us, and to those still making up their minds.
— Dr Mirela Hanke, Postdoctoral Fellow and Deputy Convenor, Living Dashboard
The report traces sixty-two decision protocols, short agreements that assign each kind of question a joint project expects to face to the discipline best placed to settle it, through their drafting, their use on review panels and a full reading of the disagreements later recorded under them. It brings together the School’s work on decision rights, panel practice and evidence stewardship across agencies, consortia, professional bodies and universities.
The reading itself was led by Eskil Nwabueze, Doctoral Candidate, with Signy Okpara, Doctoral Candidate, observing the panels. “Every protocol is a small record of what a team thought mattered before it knew,” Ms Okpara said. “Reading them back is how the School finds out what it has been asked to care about.”
The report adds a careful chapter to the University’s understanding of how its collaborators reach agreement, one the School expects to draw on as the protocols move into its teaching. The full report is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.p1cev0.