Dr Anneke Tolan, Ms Signy Okpara and Mr Halvard Nnamani follow a single hedged sentence through the causality grades of four hospital pharmacovigilance committees.
Hospital assessors re-graded the same synthetic case narratives with only the line about the reaction settling changed
Four committees gave us their afternoons across a whole season and read the same stories more carefully than anyone had a right to ask. The School owes them its thanks, and a good part of what it now understands about how a sentence travels.
— Dr Anneke Tolan, Senior Research Fellow and Deputy Convenor, Futures in Committee
It Seemed to Settle, a new research poster from the School of Emergent Priorities, turns to the part of an adverse-reaction report that says what happened once the medicine was stopped. It is led by Dr Tolan with Ms Signy Okpara, Doctoral Candidate in the School of Continuous Improvement, and Mr Halvard Nnamani, Doctoral Candidate in the School of Emergent Priorities.
The team set synthetic case narratives, committee practice and one carefully varied sentence side by side over four structured sessions, so that the wording of a report could be studied with the attention usually given to its contents. A hedged line, the authors report, lifted the share of narratives graded probable or certain from about one in five to well over half, close to what a definite line achieved, while the hedge itself seldom appeared in the justifications assessors wrote.
“We came away with more questions than we took in, which the School tends to regard as a good season,” said Ms Okpara.
The poster joins the University’s continuing investment in the close reading of ordinary documents, and the School expects to return to these narratives with the observer, rather than the wording, as the thing that changes.
The full poster is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.pzz7in.