Skip to main content
University researchers find a medicine's transfer protocol was mostly decided in the draft

University researchers find a medicine's transfer protocol was mostly decided in the draft

A new paper from the School of Emergent Priorities finds that most of the acceptance criteria in one topical cream's technology-transfer protocol took their final wording in a draft, and that the criteria a meeting settled were the ones most often raised again.

A School of Emergent Priorities paper traces 127 acceptance criteria for a topical cream through 14 drafts and 58 sets of minutes

Fifty-two of the 127 acceptance criteria in one topical cream’s technology-transfer protocol reached their approved wording without ever being discussed by name at a meeting. That is among the findings of Settled in the Draft, a new paper by Ylva Onyekwere, Doctoral Candidate, and Dr Anneke Tolan, Senior Research Fellow and Deputy Convenor, Futures in Committee, both of the School of Emergent Priorities.

Our own School keeps minutes, and I will admit we have started reading them a little differently. The question we now ask is not what the meeting decided but who was holding the pen that week.

— Ylva Onyekwere, Doctoral Candidate, School of Emergent Priorities

The paper brings a record-level, documentary lens to the handover of a medicine between the laboratory that develops it and the site that will make it, reading the protocol’s successive drafts alongside the joint team’s minutes and action list to locate where each criterion was actually settled. It finds the drafting desk doing much of the work the meeting room is credited with, and the minute serving less as a closing record than as an open invitation to return.

The study sits within the School’s continuing interest in how groups arrive at what they have agreed, a line of work that has already taken in group chats, cottage-hospital committees and the action items that outlive every meeting at which they are raised. The University is pleased to see that interest carried onto the factory floor, where it has found the same quiet machinery at work.

“Every protocol is a collaboration between the people in the room and the person at the keyboard,” said Dr Tolan. “This paper gives the second of those the attention the first has always had, and the University would welcome the conversations it starts in any committee that keeps a binder.”

The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.6nbfmi.