Skip to main content
Paper asks what a cancer network diagram is entitled to claim

Paper asks what a cancer network diagram is entitled to claim

A new paper from the School of Underlying Conditions separates three things a cancer biology paper can mean when it says one RNA "sponges" another, and proposes that the network diagrams summarising such work record the range of evidence behind each connection they draw.

A philosopher of science reads the word "sponge" in molecular cancer research as three claims of different strength

The School of Underlying Conditions has made a practice of asking what a record may say about material nobody has directly seen. With What a Sponge Must Hold, Associate Professor Ragnhild Uzoma, Lead of the Basement Relations Group, carries that practice from the core tray into the literature on the molecular mechanisms of cancer.

The paper takes a single, much-used verb, the claim that one RNA molecule “sponges” another, and distinguishes three readings of it, from a modest claim about binding to a strong claim about how a cell comes to behave as it does. It then reads the field’s network diagrams, which draw every connection with the same line, against that distinction, and proposes a light-touch annotation that would let each line declare the kind of evidence it rests on.

A diagram is a promise about what was found. I wanted to know how much each line in these figures was promising, and I think the answer will be useful well beyond the figures themselves.

— Associate Professor Ragnhild Uzoma, Lead, Basement Relations Group

The publication extends the School’s growing contribution to the philosophy of the experimental sciences, and reflects the University’s broader confidence that careful attention to the shape of a claim is itself a research capability worth building on.

The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.s38sh4.