Skip to main content
Emergent Priorities finds the case law an exceptions panel never kept

Emergent Priorities finds the case law an exceptions panel never kept

A research poster from the School of Emergent Priorities counts every definition of an exceptional case in nine years of a health-funding panel's published reasons, and finds the panel following decisions it says bind no one.

A census of nine years of published reasons traces how a health-funding panel came to cite itself

The School of Emergent Priorities collects definitions. Its doctoral researchers gather every available sense of a single word and sort them, and a new research poster brings that practice to one of the most consequential words in health funding: exceptional.

On Its Own Facts, by Sunniva Balogun, a doctoral candidate in the School, and Dr Odalys Penhallow of the School of Settled Matters, reads nine years of published determinations from a regional panel that hears requests to fund treatment outside the ordinary list. The panel’s own rules say every application is decided on its own facts.

We started with one panel and one word. There are a great many panels, and the School is in no hurry to run out of words.

— Sunniva Balogun, Doctoral Candidate, School of Emergent Priorities

The study brings archival close reading, a structured census of definitional practice and a jurisprudential account of precedent into a single frame of analysis. Across 486 determinations, the panel’s ways of describing an exceptional case narrowed from 23 to four, and the share of determinations naming an earlier one rose from 4% to 38%.

The poster sits comfortably among the University’s cross-school collaborations, in which one school’s method is lent to another’s question and both are returned in good order. Dr Penhallow, a Senior Lecturer, said the work “leaves the School of Settled Matters with more open questions than it came with, which is the arrangement the School prefers.”

The full poster is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.g9165c.