Skip to main content
Settled Matters scholars score health value sets by the decisions they keep

Settled Matters scholars score health value sets by the decisions they keep

A new paper from the School of Settled Matters and the School of Continuous Improvement proposes judging health-state value sets by whether the funding comparisons they support survive later shifts in preference, rather than by how well they fit the original survey.

A machine-learning paper asks what a quality-of-life value set still licenses once the people who valued it cannot be asked again

The best-fitting model is not the one that keeps its word. That is the headline result of The Cohort Cannot Be Re-Asked, a new paper by Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld of the School of Settled Matters and Dr Mirela Hanke of the School of Continuous Improvement, which carries the School’s long attention to the later reader into the economics of health.

A value set turns how people say they would feel in a given state of health into the numbers that cost-utility comparisons run on. At the heart of the paper is a purpose-built simulation environment, in which five successive valuation waves let the authors do what no analyst can: go back and ask again. Across that environment, the most flexible models matched their original respondents most closely and kept the fewest of their decisions, while a new training approach anchored in the decisions themselves kept 90.4% of them four waves on.

Every value set rests on an afternoon that a great many people were generous enough to give. The School has always cared about how a commitment is honoured by those who were not in the room when it was made, and it is a quiet pleasure to watch that care find a new field to work in.

— Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld, School of Settled Matters

The University regards the collaboration as an instance of exactly the cross-School traffic its research settings were arranged to encourage. “On a dashboard you learn to ask what a number is for before you ask whether it is right,” said Dr Hanke, Postdoctoral Fellow and Deputy Convenor, Living Dashboard. “It has been good to take that question somewhere it already felt at home.”

The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.eymop7.