A new paper from the School of Settled Matters follows a contested early-repayment clause through the courts and into the price of fixed-rate home loans.
Five decisions, nine lenders and the borrowers who fixed their rates in between
For four and a half years, households in one state signed fixed-rate home loans under a break-fee clause whose meaning the courts were still arguing over. Priced Before It Was Settled, a new paper by Dr Odalys Penhallow of the School of Settled Matters and Associate Professor Kwame Lindqvist of the School of Emergent Priorities, sets out what that interval was worth to the lenders who wrote those loans, and to the borrowers who took them.
I spent a long time telling people which judgments still stood. Coming at the same question through a stack of rate sheets has made me a slower, and I hope a fairer, reader of the law reports.
— Dr Odalys Penhallow, Senior Lecturer, School of Settled Matters
The study brings appellate reasoning and household finance into a single frame, reading each court decision as a signal that lenders absorbed, weighed and returned to borrowers through the price of credit. It finds that the market had treated the question as closed after a second appellate bench agreed with the first, well before the profession stopped pleading the alternative, and that the borrowers who fixed in the meantime and later moved on carried both sides of the argument.
Associate Professor Lindqvist, who directs the University’s Master of Priority Studies, said the paper would “find its way onto the reading list well before anyone has decided which week it belongs to.”
The work joins a growing shelf of University scholarship on what a legal question costs while it is still a question, and the University is pleased to see its law school and its public-finance scholars writing that shelf together.
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.mjwlpt.