Skip to main content
Readers keep the rule and lose its exception, University study finds

Readers keep the rule and lose its exception, University study finds

A new research poster from the School of Settled Matters follows 208 readers of qualified rules across four weeks and finds the exception is the first part forgotten.

A four-week recognition study from the School of Settled Matters finds that separately numbered exceptions fade fastest

Those of us who draft for a living have always pictured a reader who holds the whole of a provision in mind, exception and all. It has been an instructive season for the School to meet that reader in person, and to find them so good-natured about what they let go.

— Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld, School of Settled Matters

The Proviso Fades First, a new research poster led by Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld with Dr Odalys Penhallow and Dr Anouk Mensah, carries the School of Settled Matters out of the law library and into the memory laboratory.

The study invited 208 volunteers to read rules that came with a condition attached, and returned to them after a day, a week or a month. Framing recognition memory as a lens on everyday rule-following, it aligns the drafter’s craft with the science of remembering and surfaces a consistent pattern: the rule endures, while the case it does not cover quietly falls away. Where the exception was given a subsection of its own, it fell away sooner.

“The School has spent a long time asking how one reading of a provision comes to be the accepted one,” said Dr Penhallow, Senior Lecturer in the School. “It is a pleasure to have asked the readers as well.”

The University regards the poster as a welcome widening of its legal scholarship into the laboratory, and a sign of how naturally its schools now borrow one another’s instruments.

The full poster is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.bfry0h.