A research poster from the School of Settled Matters sets the taxed costs of forty years of stamp duty litigation against the duty those cases put in dispute.
Registry ledgers from a colonial stamp duties dispute show who carried the cost while the meaning stayed open
A question of interpretation is never only a question of meaning. Somebody keeps it open, and somebody pays for the keeping, and we are glad to have begun asking who.
— Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld, School of Settled Matters
Who Paid for a Doubtful Word, a new research poster by Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld, Dr Clemency Tredinnick, Lecturer, and Ms Sunniva Balogun, Doctoral Candidate, follows a single clause of a nineteenth-century stamp duties schedule from its first disputed assessment to the appellate ruling that settled it.
Working across registry and revenue holdings, the team brought the costs side and the duty side of 41 contested matters into one longitudinal frame, enabling a whole-of-period view of where the burden of interpretive uncertainty came to rest. The poster reports that every pound of duty in dispute drew three pounds four shillings in taxed costs, that taxpayers bore the larger share of them, and that the instruments buyers chose to lodge shifted while the word remained open.
“Every settlement I attended was priced to the shilling,” said Dr Tredinnick. “It seemed only fair to extend the same courtesy to the law’s own hesitation.”
The poster adds a ledger of its own to the University’s continuing interest in how questions come to rest, and in what it takes to bring them there.
The full poster is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.qid3sh.