A paper from the School of Settled Matters examines where the analysis period in public-building cost appraisals comes from, and proposes that each appraisal say when its recommendation would change.
Seventy-four life cycle cost comparisons, and how often the number of years they counted decided which design won
Seventy-four building appraisals, fifteen years of a capital-works gateway and one spreadsheet cell sit at the centre of a new paper from the School of Settled Matters.
In Where the Cycle Ends, Dr Odalys Penhallow, Senior Lecturer, and Dr Clemency Tredinnick, Lecturer, ask how a life cycle cost appraisal decides when a building’s life ends for the purposes of the sum. In most of the files they read, the answer was the figure the workbook already held. When the authors re-ran each comparison over longer and shorter horizons, the recommended design changed in roughly one appraisal in three.
None of this would be possible without the appraisers who kept such careful files over fifteen years. We read their work with real admiration, and we hope it shows.
— Dr Odalys Penhallow, Senior Lecturer, School of Settled Matters
The paper situates the life cycle cost comparison within a broader landscape of calculative practice, mobilising document analysis and systematic re-computation to surface how inherited parameters come to anchor public investment settings. It closes with a reporting proposal designed to sit comfortably alongside existing appraisal workflows.
The University sees the work as a natural extension of the School’s interest in how a question comes to be treated as closed, carried this time into the business case. “There is a great deal more to say about the forms we fill in without reading,” said Dr Tredinnick, “and we expect to be saying some of it for a while yet.”
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.2b8rzu.