A new paper from the School of Continuous Improvement finds that observers give a selection panellist no credit for declaring a conflict of interest after the panel's scores are shared, and some of that credit back when the scores were sealed.
Signy Okpara and Dr Thandiwe Solberg ask observers how they judge a conflict of interest declared once the scores are already in
The School of Continuous Improvement’s long engagement with the selection interview has turned, in its latest paper, to the panel’s own side of the table. Declared After the Scores, by doctoral candidate Signy Okpara and Dr Thandiwe Solberg, Senior Lecturer and Convenor of the Demo Quarter, asks what observers make of a panellist who mentions that they know a candidate only once everyone’s scores are on the screen.
Across three experiments with 3,222 adult participants, the authors find that such a declaration is judged about as harshly as a conflict that was never declared at all and came to light some other way. Observers read the timing against the score it followed, forgiving a late declarer who had marked the acquaintance down and condemning one who had marked them up. When the panellists’ scores were sealed until all were in, much of the penalty for declaring late fell away.
Most panels have a moment when someone remembers something. This paper is about that moment, and I am grateful to every participant who let us describe it to them and then sat with it for a few seconds longer than they expected.
— Signy Okpara, Doctoral Candidate, School of Continuous Improvement
The paper situates the panellist’s declaration within a broader understanding of selection as a sequence of disclosures, each carrying meaning for the observers it reaches, and positions the sealed score as one modest, practical setting through which a panel can keep its declarations legible. Dr Solberg described the work as “a conversation the School has been ready to have with itself for some time, and one it means to keep having at the pace the conversation sets.”
The University sees in the paper a further sign of how far a careful question about its own everyday processes can carry, and of the School’s readiness to put such questions to the people who watch those processes from outside.
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.i48242.