Dr Vigdis Emenike, Associate Professor Kwame Lindqvist and Dr Ingrid Vasseur bring experimental economics to the order in which a committee takes its votes.
Thirty five-member laboratory committees, three running orders and a shared aquifer's pumping cap
Thirty small committees sat down in a University laboratory to settle how much water a shared aquifer could give up. Each was handed three options and a fixed running order. Not every committee was handed the same names for those options, and that, a new research poster finds, was enough to change what they decided.
Holding Out for the Low Cap, by Dr Vigdis Emenike, Senior Lecturer in the School of Underlying Conditions, with Associate Professor Kwame Lindqvist and Dr Ingrid Vasseur of the School of Emergent Priorities, shows members ready to think several votes ahead while the options carried letters. Once the options were named as pumping caps, few would cast a vote against the lowest of them, even where that vote was the only way to keep the highest one from passing.
Every committee I have sat on believed it was deciding the question in front of it. This work invites the University to wonder, gently, how much of that deciding the running order had already done, and we are content to leave the question with the next committee that meets.
— Associate Professor Kwame Lindqvist, Director, Master of Priority Studies
The poster connects a long scholarly conversation about collective choice with the everyday stewardship of shared resources, translating the formal grammar of agendas into a setting any catchment board or standing committee would recognise. It marks a further step in the steady traffic of ideas between the two Schools, which the University counts among its quieter strengths.
Dr Vasseur said she expected the findings to be “read with interest in any room where a motion has been moved and then amended”.
The full poster is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.hpmk0x.