A new paper from the School of Emergent Priorities reads a district drift panel's full archive of determinations as the life story of a legal fiction, and asks how the fiction might be kept honest.
Hedvig Anyanwu follows a complaints panel's modelled bystander from a passing illustration to a pre-filled form field
I expect the lawyers who read it and the growers who read it will each find a different paragraph to object to. That seems a fair sign it is about something both of them recognise, and I would welcome hearing from either.
— Hedvig Anyanwu, Doctoral Candidate, School of Emergent Priorities
The Neighbour Who Was Never There, a new paper by Hedvig Anyanwu, brings the jurisprudence of legal fictions to an unexpected setting: the written decisions of a rural panel that hears complaints of pesticide spray drift between neighbours.
The paper follows a single figure through the panel’s archive, a modelled adult standing at the boundary fence for one pass of the sprayer, and shows how it moves from illustration to standard to settled fact across four editions of the panel’s practice note. Setting that figure beside the reasonable person of negligence, it surfaces a quiet inversion at the heart of the panel’s reasoning, and closes with a measured, practical account of how a fiction can be retained and still kept honest.
The School of Emergent Priorities regards the work as a strong early return on its commitment to doctoral scholarship that travels between disciplines, and as a timely contribution to the University’s wider conversation about the standards that come to stand in for the people they describe. It positions the School to take part in that conversation with a doctoral voice that is attentive to records, to institutions and to the small grammatical choices through which both change.
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.ag0m4x.