The School of Settled Matters' new display campaign recruits its Semester 1 intake with a question from organic chemistry, put to students as a case to be made.
A portrait signage campaign asks prospective students whether a cyclopropane ring opens in steps or all at once, and to argue the answer
Students joining the School of Settled Matters in Semester 1 will be asked to defend a curly arrow. Stepwise or Concerted, Make the Case, the School’s new campaign for campus screens and signage panels, takes the question of how a three-membered carbon ring comes apart and offers it to prospective students as a matter for argument rather than recall.
I would rather a student arrived with a question about which way the electrons went than with a settled view of it. The ones who come in undecided tend to make the better advocates, and the ring gives them a great deal to be undecided about.
— Dr Odalys Penhallow, Senior Lecturer and Lead, Received Readings Group, School of Settled Matters
The campaign aligns the School’s practice of reading decided cases with the mechanistic reasoning of organic chemistry, positioning the curly arrow as an instrument of persuasion as much as of description, and the intake as a point of entry to the Received Readings Group’s wider interest in how an open question comes to be treated as closed.
In its small print, the poster cites three of the University’s published works: What the Lattice Keeps, Nine Inactive Fractions and Decided Before the Meeting. The University sees in the campaign a fair measure of the School’s ambition to hold chemistry’s open questions to the same standard of argument it brings to the law’s. Prospective students can register their interest through the University’s course listings ahead of the teaching period.
The full poster is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.vxpoxr.