Skip to main content
Law school asks that an open question be recorded as open

Law school asks that an open question be recorded as open

The School of Settled Matters has lodged a submission to the Department of Policy Settings' review of outputs in dialogue form, proposing a fourth option under which a statement of finding is recorded only once its authors accept the settled wording.

The School of Settled Matters answers the Department's dialogue-form consultation by proposing a statement that authors and the Office agree together

The School of Settled Matters has asked the Department of Policy Settings to let the University’s researchers say, on the record, that a question remains open.

The request comes in Stated Between the Parties, the School’s response to the Department’s consultation on how the statement of finding should apply to outputs written as dialogues. Prepared by Dr Odalys Penhallow and Dr Clemency Tredinnick, it answers five of the paper’s six questions and proposes an option the Department had not listed: a statement settled by the Office from the authors’ draft, and entered only once the authors have accepted its final wording.

Lawyers spend much of their working lives writing down things they do not personally hold. It seemed only courteous to explain that to the Department, and to suggest a way of recording it.

— Dr Odalys Penhallow, Senior Lecturer and Lead, Received Readings Group

The submission reads the University’s research record through the older vocabulary of the trade account, in which a balance rendered by one party is distinguished from a balance both parties have examined and accepted. It connects that distinction with the School’s published work on purchase-order closures, suspense accounts and contested lending clauses, positioning authorship, assent and record-keeping as parts of a single institutional practice.

A reply of this kind is how the University’s consultative settings are meant to work, and the University is pleased to see its law school among the first to take part. Dr Tredinnick said the School had tried “to answer only the questions we could answer well, and to leave the others for colleagues who know them better.”

The full submission is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.8123yn.