Skip to main content
University historian finds a pigment's lucky accident arrived late

University historian finds a pigment's lucky accident arrived late

A new history and philosophy of science paper finds that the chance event in a colour laboratory's best-known discovery story entered the story only after a disagreement over credit had been resolved.

A School of Settled Matters paper reads fourteen accounts of a laboratory blue against the file note that settled who found it

The accident at the heart of a colour laboratory’s best-known discovery story did not enter that story until a disagreement over credit had been put to rest, according to Nobody’s Accident, a new paper by Dr Clemency Tredinnick, Lecturer in the School of Settled Matters.

Every good story deserves a second reading, and a good many of them deserve a first. It has been a privilege to give this one both.

— Dr Clemency Tredinnick, Lecturer, School of Settled Matters

Through a close reading of bench records, internal paperwork, house publications and oral testimony, Dr Tredinnick sets fourteen tellings of one pigment’s discovery beside the record of the dispute that preceded them, surfacing a progressive transfer of credit from individual contribution to circumstance and, over three decades, to the institution itself. The paper positions the discovery account as a mechanism of closure in its own right, and invites historians of the colour industries to treat the arrival of chance in a narrative as evidence to be dated rather than a detail to be enjoyed.

The work carries the School’s interest in how questions come to rest from the land registry to the laboratory bench, a widening of jurisdiction the University regards as entirely in keeping with its commitment to reading across the disciplines. Dr Tredinnick was careful to share the credit. “Any discovery has more people standing in front of it than a story can hold,” she said. “I have tried to leave room for them.”

The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.17p9hh.