A new research poster finds that a racing appeals panel decided its case on a narrow ground, and that the panels which followed settled a much wider one.
A School of Settled Matters poster reads one appeal over a neuropeptide the horse makes itself, and the 41 decisions that cited it afterwards
Every registry has a drawer of decisions that are cited far more often than they are read. It has been a privilege to spend a season with one of them, and I hope the profession will forgive us for reading it.
— Dr Odalys Penhallow, Senior Lecturer, School of Settled Matters
With those words, Dr Odalys Penhallow introduces What the Horse Makes Itself, a new research poster from the School of Settled Matters written with Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld. It is a case note in the classical manner, on an appeal in which a horse’s post-race sample held a neuropeptide the animal also produces for itself.
The panel allowed the appeal on a narrow footing. The authors then follow the ruling through 41 later decisions over nine seasons, and find that 30 of them applied not what the panel decided but a broader remark its presiding member made along the way.
The work brings together close reading of published reasons, a structured account of how a holding travels, and the School’s long engagement with the question of when a point of law can be said to be closed. It is the kind of patient attention to the record that the University has come to count among its quieter strengths.
“The School is still learning how much of what it knows it has simply stopped arguing about,” said Associate Professor Threlkeld, “and it is good to see it doing that learning in public.”
The poster was prepared with the Received Readings Group, the School’s founding research group.
The full poster is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.a5kv5l.