Skip to main content
Settled Matters paper finds where a symmetry convention leaves nothing

Settled Matters paper finds where a symmetry convention leaves nothing

Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld of the School of Settled Matters proves which finite symmetry groups lose their whole second-order optical response to Kleinman's permutation condition, and finds a single family, each member losing one dimension.

A pure mathematics paper classifies the crystal symmetries whose second-harmonic response vanishes under Kleinman's condition

There is no instrument in the School of Settled Matters’ newest paper, and no sample. What Kleinman’s Condition Leaves, by Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld, is a work of pure mathematics, and it settles a question about optical crystals entirely on paper: for which arrangements of symmetry does a widely used simplifying convention erase a material’s second-harmonic response altogether?

Most of what I know about a rule I learned from the cases where it gives nothing back. I owe a great deal to everyone who ever wrote out one of these tables by hand.

— Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld, School of Settled Matters

Working from the representation theory of the rotation group, the paper sets the classical crystallographic tables against every finite symmetry group of three-dimensional space, aligning the vocabulary of invariant theory with the long-standing practice of optical characterisation. Its answer is compact: one family of symmetry groups, each surrendering exactly one dimension, with two familiar crystal classes among them and no others. Along the way it accounts, class by class, for what the convention costs across all twenty-one non-centrosymmetric classes.

The University welcomes the paper as a measure of how far a settled habit of reading can travel from the statute book, and as a further step in the School’s widening engagement with the mathematical sciences.

The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.wvifbz.