A paper from the School of Settled Matters logs every question asked about a laboratory's twenty-two-step purification routine over fourteen months, and finds the quiet steps are the ones whose author has left the building.
Fourteen months at a protein purification bench show which steps a newcomer is taught not to question, and what the laboratory says about them afterwards
Four steps in a working laboratory’s twenty-two-step purification routine were not questioned aloud once in fourteen months. A paper published today by the School of Settled Matters, The Step Nobody Asks About, reports what the other eighteen attracted instead, and what the difference turns on.
Dr Odalys Penhallow and Dr Anneke Tolan embedded with a recombinant protein group for a full year of its production calendar, coding all 1,476 questions its members put to the procedure at the bench and in group meetings, then reading that traffic against nine years of the protocol’s own revisions. Nine steps carried most of the argument. The settled ones proved to be those whose originating member had since moved on, and which incoming researchers are advised, helpfully and in almost identical words, to leave alone.
What we found is a kind of institutional memory that runs in the wrong direction. The School studies how a question comes to be closed, and it has been instructive to watch one close in a setting where nobody intended to close anything.
— Dr Odalys Penhallow, Senior Lecturer, School of Settled Matters
Dr Anneke Tolan, Senior Research Fellow and Deputy Convenor of Futures in Committee, said the fieldwork “gave the School a durable way of asking what a practice is keeping a record of”. The University regards the collaboration across its research precincts as an encouraging indication of where its interdisciplinary posture can lead.
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.ouemmc.