Skip to main content
First-year tutors built their own case law on AI use, paper finds

First-year tutors built their own case law on AI use, paper finds

Dr Odalys Penhallow spent a teaching year with the sessional tutors of a first-year programme and traces how their answers to students' questions about generative AI became a body of rulings with names, a register and a settled core.

A School of Settled Matters ethnography follows one teaching room's answers about a course's AI clause until they hardened into precedent

The question of what students may do with generative AI is usually answered in policy. A new paper from the School of Settled Matters goes looking for the answer somewhere smaller: the shared room where a first-year programme’s sessional tutors keep the kettle, the pigeonholes and, as it turns out, a spreadsheet of everything they have ever been asked.

“Is This Like the Flashcards One?”, by Dr Odalys Penhallow, follows that spreadsheet across a full teaching year, from its first entry on flashcards to the forty-one it held by the year’s end.

I went into that room expecting to learn how tutors read a rule. I came out knowing a good deal more about how my own School reads one, and I am grateful to the room for showing me.

— Dr Odalys Penhallow, Senior Lecturer, School of Settled Matters

Bringing participant observation, interviews and the programme’s own correspondence into a single account of teaching practice, the paper positions the tutors’ room as a site where institutional settings are interpreted, stabilised and handed on. It attends closely to the moment a question stops travelling up the line, and to the ways a changing tool can unsettle what a rule had settled.

The study sits comfortably within the School’s continuing interest in how questions come to rest, and the University welcomes it as a patient account of policy as it is actually lived at the seminar-room door.

The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.csborv.