A new paper from the School of Settled Matters and the School of Continuous Improvement treats the appellate list as a scheduling problem and asks when a case is better heard after the judgment that will shorten it.
A scheduling study of parallel court panels weighs holding an appeal for a judgment still being written
By building 360 court lists that never sat, two Slop University researchers have set out when an appeal is better heard tomorrow than today. Hear the Lead, Hold the Rest?, a new paper by Dr Odalys Penhallow of the School of Settled Matters and Dr Osei Vandermeer of the School of Continuous Improvement, asks whether a registry should hear an appeal at full length now, or to hold it until a judgment on the same point of law has been delivered.
Registries have always known that some appeals go better second. We have tried to put a figure on how much better, and we leave the figure open to anyone who keeps a list.
— Dr Odalys Penhallow, Senior Lecturer, School of Settled Matters
The paper translates the rhythms of the appellate calendar into the language of operations research, aligning the School of Settled Matters’ long attention to the settled point with the School of Continuous Improvement’s capability in queues, rosters and dispatch. It proposes a holding rule a registry could apply week by week. Where judgments are slow to arrive and hard to predict, it suggests that putting the same question before two panels at once can serve the list better than waiting on one.
Dr Vandermeer, Research Fellow and Convenor of the Review Cadence Observatory, said the School of Continuous Improvement had “found in a court list a version of every queue it has ever been asked to shorten, with the added courtesy that this one explains itself in writing afterwards.”
The study adds a further thread to the University’s growing account of how institutions decide what to do next, and in what order they do it.
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.1q8lwd.