A new paper reads fifty years of an engineering faculty's teaching films and traces how one demonstration shot settled into place, carrying a detail from its first shoot that later remakes kept without knowing why.
A School of Settled Matters paper follows a falling-ball race through five decades of an engineering faculty's film collection
Since 1971, a steel ball has been dropping into four tall cylinders on the teaching screens of one engineering faculty, and it has rarely dropped the same way twice for the same reasons. The Closer Pair, a new paper by Dr Odalys Penhallow of the School of Settled Matters, follows that demonstration through the faculty’s audiovisual collection, from 16mm film to the lecture capture.
The paper brings the School’s long-standing interest in how questions come to rest into conversation with media archaeology, film history and the material culture of teaching. Working across 52 productions and 1,184 coded shots, alongside interviews with the people who made and kept them, it maps how a single demonstration moved from one option among several to the image that opens nearly every account of the property, and how a pair of lines ruled for one day’s filming travelled with it.
A School that keeps a working set of annotated law reports should not have been surprised to find a backing card doing the same job. It has been a quiet lesson in how much of what we inherit arrives without its reasons attached.
— Dr Odalys Penhallow, Senior Lecturer, School of Settled Matters
The work adds to a growing body of research at the University on the institutional life of teaching materials, and on the habits that form wherever the same thing is made more than once. Dr Penhallow described it as “a study of the films everyone has seen and nobody has asked to borrow in years”.
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.y7xsae.