A new musicology paper from the School of Settled Matters reads four seasons of an orchestra's reviews against the ledger of the reed-maker who supplied its oboes.
A regional orchestra's critics heard the darkening as one player's, and a reed-maker's working ledger suggests a wider cast
Dr Clemency Tredinnick, Lecturer in the School of Settled Matters, has turned the School’s habit of close reading towards the concert hall. Heard as Hers, her new paper, revisits four seasons in which a regional orchestra’s critics heard its principal oboe grow darker, and sets their reviews beside a source they never saw: the working ledger of the reed-maker who supplied every reed the section played.
Orchestras keep a great many records, and the people who keep the quieter ones are often the most generous with them. I am grateful to everyone who let me sit in on that conversation.
— Dr Clemency Tredinnick, Lecturer, School of Settled Matters
The paper brings archival reading, critical reception, broadcast listening and the composition of the cane itself into a single account, aligning 570 critical mentions of the oboe with the bale-by-bale record of the workshop’s materials. The darkening, it finds, arrived with a new bale of cane rather than with the new principal, and left when the cane did.
The work marks a confident first step for the School into the study of musical practice, and sits comfortably within the University’s wider attention to the records that working communities keep about themselves.
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.r8qi5l.