Skip to main content
New paper weighs what an unsettled tax word cost the firms waiting on it

New paper weighs what an unsettled tax word cost the firms waiting on it

A paper from the Schools of Settled Matters and Emergent Priorities finds that doubt over the word "experimental" held back research at the firms it touched about as much as losing the concession did.

Five years of divided tribunal decisions over one statutory definition, followed through the registrations and research of 3,406 firms

Five years of uncertainty over a single word in an innovation tax concession weighed on the research of the firms it touched about as heavily as losing the concession outright, according to What the Word Was Worth, a new paper by Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld of the School of Settled Matters and Dr Lindiwe Achterberg of the School of Emergent Priorities.

The paper brings the methods of both Schools to a single question, and reflects the University’s conviction that a question asked in one discipline is often best answered with the instruments of another.

Lawyers are used to arriving after the argument is over. It has been a pleasure, for once, to arrive with colleagues who could say what the waiting was worth, and to have something to bring them in return.

— Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld, School of Settled Matters

Bringing together concession registrations and survey returns, the authors build a longitudinal picture of how a community of innovating firms navigated an extended period of interpretive ambiguity, and how a single appellate decision recalibrated its relationship with the concession. Firms whose work the court brought within the word recovered their research effort; firms it left outside largely kept the work and stopped registering it. Within two years, most new registrations described their research in the judgment’s own words.

“The Trajectory Analytics Group has followed a great many questions,” said Dr Achterberg, Lecturer and Deputy Director of the Group. “This is the first we have followed all the way to an answer, and we intend to make a habit of it.”

The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.ye8zvo.