Skip to main content
Theology of reception sheds light on how a seminar came to trust a proof

Theology of reception sheds light on how a seminar came to trust a proof

A research poster from the School of Settled Matters reads an algebra seminar's minute books through the theology of reception, tracing how a long proof came to be used as settled before any check of it was recorded as complete.

A poster from the School of Settled Matters follows six years of seminar minutes as a contested proof moved from assumption to settled use

Theologians have long held that a council’s decree is not finished on the day it is issued; it is finished when the faithful take it up. A new research poster from the School of Settled Matters suggests that a long mathematical proof may be finished in much the same way.

Received Before It Was Checked, by Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld and Dr Odalys Penhallow, brings the theology of reception into dialogue with the record-keeping of a working mathematics department. Coding 121 minute entries across twelve semesters of one algebra seminar, the team surfaces a quiet transition from conditional to settled use of a contested result, a transition that no recorded decision accounts for and that the seminar’s checking had already stopped short of.

We came to the minutes expecting to find a verdict and found a habit instead. The School will be thinking about the difference between the two for some time.

— Associate Professor Anselm Threlkeld, School of Settled Matters

The work joins a widening body of University scholarship in which one discipline lends its vocabulary to another’s archive, and the University expects to see a good deal more of it. “Every department keeps minutes,” said Dr Penhallow. “It has been a pleasure to work somewhere that is willing to read its own back.”

The full poster is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.yviiay.