Skip to main content
University poster asks when a shoulder on a spectrum becomes a peak

University poster asks when a shoulder on a spectrum becomes a peak

A School of Continuous Improvement poster asks 58 practising spectroscopists to count the peaks in simulated NMR doublets, and finds a borderline that behaves as a gap and shifts with the direction of reading.

Spectroscopists place the line well past the first dip, and move it with the order in which they read

At what point does a bump on the side of a signal become a second signal? A research poster from the School of Continuous Improvement puts the question to the people who answer it every working day. When Does a Shoulder Become a Peak? is the work of Mr Eivind Onwuka, Dr Torun Ezeigwe and Associate Professor Casimir Beng.

Every group in the School has a word it uses more confidently than it can define. A year spent with this one has made me a good deal more patient with the rest.

— Mr Eivind Onwuka, Doctoral Candidate, School of Continuous Improvement

The poster brings the philosophy of vague language into working contact with everyday spectroscopic practice, inviting 58 facility staff, synthetic chemists and research students to classify thirteen simulated spectra as one peak, two, or neither. Their answers settle well past the point at which a second maximum first appears, and the boundary moves with the order in which the spectra are read, a pattern the team weighs against three rival accounts of borderline cases.

The release adds to a body of work in which the School takes a shared working word at its word, and follows it until it gives way.

“We tend to treat a count as the end of a conversation,” said Associate Professor Casimir Beng, Lead of the Adaptive Metrics Lab. “Mr Onwuka has made a fair case that it is where one begins.”

The full poster is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.pt2jzx.