Skip to main content
University paper finds the taxi exam now tests when to overrule the satnav

University paper finds the taxi exam now tests when to overrule the satnav

Dr Petra Umbile and Dr Anneke Tolan follow a hire-car licensing board's street-knowledge examination from recited routes to questions about when a driver should overrule the device on the dashboard.

Forty years of one licensing board's street-knowledge papers, from recited routes to device questions

At one regional licensing board, a hire-car licence no longer certifies that its holder knows the way. According to a new paper from the School of Emergent Priorities, it certifies that they know when the satnav does not.

Where the Knowledge Went, by Dr Petra Umbile and Dr Anneke Tolan, follows that board through four decades of its street-knowledge examination. The authors worked through the board’s bound question papers, its committee’s minutes and the recollections of its examiners, and sat in on oral examinations across a full licensing year. They trace how a test once built on routes recited from memory came to centre on a new kind of question: a device’s proposed route set on the page, and a candidate asked whether to follow it.

A School that plans for a living spends a good deal of time deciding what to hand over and what to keep. It was instructive to watch another institution make that call carefully, one question at a time.

— Dr Petra Umbile, Postdoctoral Fellow

The paper situates the board’s examination within a wider conversation about expertise, delegation and the shifting settlements between professional judgement and the systems that increasingly support it. It adds to the School’s growing attention to the priorities institutions keep quietly, rather than the ones they announce.

“Most organisations have a room like that examination room somewhere,” said Dr Anneke Tolan, Senior Research Fellow and Deputy Convenor, Futures in Committee. “We would be glad to be invited into a few more of them.”

The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.6h8u41.