Dr Vigdis Emenike brings eighteenth-century political philosophy and a famously circular novel to bear on the minute books of a rural groundwater trust, and asks how an institution keeps its authority once its founding reason has lapsed.
A new paper follows one district's groundwater trust as it rewrites, shortens and finally restores the story of its own founding
Fourteen volumes of minutes, an Italian philosopher of history and a novel whose last sentence runs on into its first are the materials of the latest paper from the School of Underlying Conditions. In As Constituted, Dr Vigdis Emenike, Senior Lecturer, reads the governance record of one inland district’s groundwater users’ trust alongside Giambattista Vico and Finnegans Wake, and proposes that a commons institution endures less by remembering why it was founded than by telling the story again.
A bore is read every month whether or not anyone remembers why. I came to this work wanting to know what keeps the reading going, and found the trust had been answering that question in its own minutes for ninety years. My part was mostly to listen.
— Dr Vigdis Emenike, Senior Lecturer, School of Underlying Conditions
The paper situates the trust’s successive rulebooks within a wider conversation between political theory and literary scholarship, bringing long-run institutional records into dialogue with questions of founding, custom and legitimacy that have animated the field for generations. It positions the School’s established fieldwork practice as a resource for the humanities, and the humanities as a resource for the field.
For a University that keeps its own records with some care, the paper is a welcome reminder of how much an institution can hold in its preambles, and it extends the School’s growing body of work on the people and practices that surround a measurement long after it was first taken.
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.al1juj.