Dr Vigdis Emenike's new essay asks what the structural geologist's drafting-table check on folded rock would require of a political restoration.
A School of Underlying Conditions essay reads the balanced cross-section as a test for any claim to restore the past
A drafting-table check that mountain geologists apply to their own drawings has found a second setting in political theory. In Admissible and Viable, Senior Lecturer Dr Vigdis Emenike of the School of Underlying Conditions takes the balanced cross-section, in which a section through folded and faulted rock is accepted only if it can be laid out flat again with nothing added and nothing lost, and asks what the same discipline would demand of a society seeking to return to an earlier settlement.
Every season a student team hands me a section that balances and that I would not have drawn myself. I used to mark those down. I now think the marking scheme had more to learn than the students did.
— Dr Vigdis Emenike, Senior Lecturer, School of Underlying Conditions
The essay moves between the field course’s mapping exercise and long-standing questions of legitimacy, feasibility and redress, positioning conservation as the shared ground on which competing accounts of the present can be compared and, where they fail to add up, seen to fail. It gives particular attention to the rock that erosion has already carried away, which the geologist neither ignores nor pretends to recover.
The work extends the School’s broader engagement with what a partial record can responsibly be asked to say, and the University welcomes its arrival in a conversation well beyond the borefield.
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.927pdv.