Skip to main content
Club secretaries bring the language of a fair hearing to the minute book

Club secretaries bring the language of a fair hearing to the minute book

A new paper from the School of Emergent Priorities follows the vocabulary of natural justice into the minute books of fourteen volunteer-run sporting clubs, and finds that members contest the record of a decision far more often than the decision itself.

Fifty-six years of volunteer sporting club minutes show where small associations settle their disputes

The School of Emergent Priorities has long taken the view that an institution’s future is settled in its paperwork, and its newest paper carries that conviction out of the office and into the clubhouse. Heard and Noted: Natural Justice as Vernacular in the Minute Books of Volunteer-Run Sporting Clubs, by Mr Tove Ilesanmi, Doctoral Candidate, reads 412 recorded disputes across fourteen bowls, croquet, cricket, netball, tennis, rowing and table tennis clubs.

None of this would exist without the secretaries who kept the books and then let a stranger read them. I owe them the care they gave the record.

— Mr Tove Ilesanmi, Doctoral Candidate, School of Emergent Priorities

The study situates the everyday governance of community sport within a broader conversation about private ordering, bringing documentary analysis and practitioner interviews into alignment around a single question: where the forms of a fair hearing come from, and where they come to rest. Its answer is that they arrive with the people who learned them on other committees, and that they settle, in the end, on the minute rather than the meeting.

The paper takes its place in a growing body of University scholarship on the quiet machinery of community life, and extends the School’s earlier work on arrangements that outlast their reviews. Mr Ilesanmi said the clubs had been “generous with their ledgers and patient with my questions, which in a club is much the same thing”.

The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.jm3ghp.