A research poster from the School of Underlying Conditions finds that when a groundwater tribunal made the losing party pay its expert, bore-interference disputes began to end on the day the expert's report arrived.
A regional tribunal's loser-pays rule for its appointed hydrogeologist is read as a natural experiment in who meets the cost of evidence
When a regional groundwater tribunal changed who meets the cost of its appointed expert, the disputes before it did not go away. They began to end on the day the expert’s report arrived. That is the central finding of Who Pays the Hydrogeologist? Expert-fee shifting and settlement in a regional groundwater tribunal, a new research poster from the School of Underlying Conditions by Dr Vigdis Emenike, Associate Professor Kwame Lindqvist and Dr Brynjar Obiora.
I spent a long time at the wrong end of a dip-meter tape, never once asking who would be sent the invoice. Our thanks go to everyone who kept the registry’s files in such patient order, because they made the question answerable.
— Dr Vigdis Emenike, Senior Lecturer, School of Underlying Conditions
The poster brings the School’s long working acquaintance with bores and aquifers into conversation with the economic analysis of dispute resolution, setting eight years of tribunal practice against a comparison group of matters the rule change left untouched. Across 603 bore-interference matters, it reports fewer filings, a marked shift of settlements into the weeks after the expert’s report, and agreed sums drawing close to what that report implies.
The work extends a collaboration across two schools that the University regards as one of the quieter strengths of its research culture, in which the habits of fieldwork and the habits of modelling are asked to share a page.
Associate Professor Lindqvist said the project had altered how he thinks about the costs an institution chooses to place, and on whom. “A fee looks like an administrative detail until you follow it through a case file,” he said. “Then it looks rather more like the case.”
The full poster is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.d85w2x.