Dr Vigdis Emenike and Dr Mirela Hanke find that operators take a decision-support tool's advice to measure more far more readily than its advice to measure less, unless stopping is offered as a pause.
A two-year field study of a groundwater monitoring advisor and the nine hydrographers who reviewed its every recommendation
Decision-support tools are usually judged on the advice they give. A new paper from the School of Underlying Conditions and the School of Continuous Improvement judges one on the advice its users chose to take. Advice to Stop: Asymmetric Uptake of Retirement Recommendations in a Groundwater Monitoring Decision-Support Tool, by Dr Vigdis Emenike and Dr Mirela Hanke, follows a regional monitoring network through two years of quarterly review.
A recommendation is only ever half of a decision, and it has been a pleasure to spend two years with the other half. The Living Dashboard has always given tools and the people using them equal standing, and this work sits very comfortably there.
— Dr Mirela Hanke, Postdoctoral Fellow and Deputy Convenor, Living Dashboard
Working alongside the hydrographers who review the network’s schedule, the authors traced every recommendation a value-of-information advisor made and then trialled a reframing of the advice operators most consistently set aside. The study brings decision analysis, interface design and the practice of the field round together into a single, operator-centred account of uptake. Advice to add a measurement was taken four times in five; advice to retire a bore, about once in eight. Offered instead as a four-quarter pause, retirement was accepted close to half the time, and most pauses were quietly renewed when they came due.
“There is a great deal of care in a pause,” said Dr Vigdis Emenike, Senior Lecturer, School of Underlying Conditions. “I think our tools have room for more of it.”
The University counts the paper among a quietly expanding shelf of work in which its schools look at a decision from both ends, and it is pleased to see two of them meet over a single review screen.
The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.gylhk7.