Skip to main content
University paper works out how long a rating scale should be

University paper works out how long a rating scale should be

A paper from the School of Emergent Priorities derives the number of grades a lender's internal rating scale can support, and the point at which a supervisor's testing stops the scale from growing.

A lender's list of credit grades is treated as a histogram, and the number of grades its data can support is derived from the size of its book

The School of Emergent Priorities has long taken an interest in lists that somebody, at some point, decided the length of. Its latest paper takes up one of the more consequential: the scale of grades on which a lender sorts the people and firms it has lent to. The Cube Root of the Book: Optimal Granularity of an Internal Rating Scale under Backtesting, by Dr Runa Adegoke, Senior Lecturer and Convenor of the Strategic Drift Survey, and Dr Iben Chikere, Lecturer, is published today.

A scale is a decision that goes on being made every morning by people who were not in the room for it. We have tried to say what the room should have been told, and we expect to keep saying it for some time.

— Dr Runa Adegoke, Senior Lecturer and Convenor, Strategic Drift Survey

The paper brings a statistical lens to a question of institutional design, aligning the fineness of a rating scale with the evidence available to sustain it. Its three propositions connect the size of a lending book to the length of the scale that book can support, position each grade boundary against the borrowers on either side of it, and identify a supervisory setting under which the scale ceases to lengthen however large the lender becomes. A worked illustration on a stylised book accompanies the formal results.

The University regards the paper as a considered addition to its growing body of work on how categories are set and then lived with. Dr Chikere said the collaboration had been “a reminder that the middle of a scale is where most of us spend our working lives, and that it repays a visit”.

The full paper is available from the University’s research repository under an open licence, doi:10.5555/slop.w1970n.